Why We Don’t Support Volunteering in Orphanages

Why We Don’t Support Volunteering in Orphanages

Defining an institution or orphanage

In its broadest sense, an orphanage can be defined as an institution that takes care of children without parents or who are separated from their parents and family, living with a large number of unrelated children in the same building/compound, until they can be adopted.

You can read more about how to best define an institution / orphanage here.

The problem with orphanages /residential care

Children in orphanages or residential care are generally isolated from their extended families and communities. Orphanage staff are often unqualified domestic workers, who are instructed not to give any one child more attention than another. At best they are given food and shelter, at worst they are neglected and unloved.

Evidence has also shown that living in institutions harms children’s health and emotional development.

However, there are hundreds of thousands of children all over the world who have no one to care for them, and the only recourse is to take them off the streets and give them shelter in an orphanage. This is not ideal, but in many cases it is the only option the state might have.

Where we send our volunteers

We send our volunteers to work in communities or with organisations whose aims are to raise children in foster families or to give them  a family home, whilst keeping them as closely connected to their families and communities as possible.

Children and foster parents at Kitezh Children’s Community

Kitezh and Orion Children’s Communities in Russia are pioneering villages of foster families who have taken children out of institutions and raised them as part of families within a community setting. The children receive the love and security they need to grow up into confident, caring young people. The Kitezh School has become widely recognised as a successful, experimental school. Over 100 children have lived with families in Kitezh and Orion since it began in 1992.

In Kenya, the mission of the Kithoka Amani Community Home (KACH) is to keep orphaned and vulnerable children in the community where they grew up, preserving their network of support. They can continue to attend their local school as well as keeping their close relationships with extended families, whilst housing, food and funding for education are provided by the Amani Home family.

Community members contribute to various aspects of its running in order to ensure integration with the community as well as sustainability. It is set up to be self-sustaining through its network of cottage industries. International Peace Initiatives (IPI) itself was founded by Dr. Karambu Ringera and it is dedicated to supporting and funding initiatives that mitigate the effects of poverty, disease, discrimination and violence. Karambu’s vision was to set up a grass-roots community-building project, with a particular focus on improving the lives of vulnerable children.

Children at Kithoka Amani Community Home

The fine line

There are circumstances when a child cannot live with extended family – families destroyed by war, HIV/AIDS, extreme poverty, alcohol and substance abuse and worse. There are not enough grandparents and potential foster or adoptive parents to care for all the children who are suffering as a result of losing the care of their parents. Who will take children off the streets if there is no government support to help them?

A holistic, humanitarian approach is one that considers all circumstances and commits to caring for a child with love and attention, while maintaining his or her connection to their communities and families wherever possible. This can also mean providing skills trainings to family members to enable them to take care of the children, or simply paying for school fees for children whilst they continue living with family members. In some cases however, it can be in the child’s best interest to live in a safer, more secure environment.

In the case of Kithoka Amani Children’s Home in Kenya, children are kept as closely connected to their extended family and community as possible. At Kitezh Community in Russia, many of the children regain contact with their natural parents or siblings as they grow older, and are the richer for their positive experience in Kitezh.

We encourage our volunteers to interact with all the children in our projects naturally and to realise that these children are the lucky ones! They can learn, they can play and they can benefit from knowing someone from another culture. That understanding will make the world a more peaceful, harmonious place to live in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

three × five =

you can make an Impact

Join our dedicated team of volunteers and experience the joy of giving back, while making a meaningful impact in the lives of individuals and the community

you can make a difference

Your contribution has the power to make a difference in the lives of those in need, enabling us to continue our vital work and create positive change

Stay in touch with us

Subscribe to our emails today to receive our latest news, updates, and inspiring stories.

susie Kemp

Susie has 30+ experience as a creative copywriter, editor, and proofreader, starting out as a 20-year-old copywriter in the Mad Men world of early 1990s advertising in South Africa. Ever since, she’s had a love affair with creative conceptualisation, thinking outside of the box, writing to a deadline, and being thrown in the deep end!

She took an MSc in Publishing at Edinburgh Napier University as a mature student, in 2015, and continues to keep herself busy working as a copy-editor, proofreader and copywriter in book publishing, corporate communications, and publishing project management.

Apart from her love of working with independent authors, Susie has a fondness for working in the third sector and likes to use her corporate communications and marketing experience to support projects close to her heart. She has lived and worked in the Findhorn area for 25 years, and has been involved in a number of third sector projects and organisations, and family businesses.

Working at Ecologia Youth Trust helps Susie to live in integrity with her values of supporting the next generation to be the best that they can be, and she sees it as a way to give back to Mama Africa, the beloved continent on which she was born.

Ellen Shaw

Ellen joined the Ecologia team in June 2018 as Marketing and Communications Manager. Ellen has lived in Scotland for 6 years and has worked for non-profit and charitable organisations across varied fields. She currently shares her passion for helping young people through Ecologia Youth Trust and she works as a dancer and dance teacher in her spare time.

Robyn Cooper

Robyn is the Associate Director of International Projects, having previously worked within the team as a Project Development and Marketing Officer from April 2019 until May 2021. As Associate Director, Robyn is co-leading the International side of Ecologia with Founder and Director, Liza Hollingshead, bringing a new energy into Ecologia as they look towards the future of the charity.

Liza Hollingshead

Liza is the founder of Ecologia and Director of International Projects. She was born and educated in South Africa and worked there as a high school teacher. She moved to live in the Findhorn Community in 1974. She started Ecologia in 1995 after being introduced to Dmitry Morozov, the founder of Kitezh Children’s Community in Russia, and was inspired to support the community in its mission to rescue orphaned children from institutions and give them homes, families and education in a supportive environment.

This led to projects supporting disadvantaged youth and children in South East Asia and in East Africa. TRead more about Liza’s story here.